We serve all of NEW YORK State
Phone: (631) 422-6650
Fax: (631) 422-6577
E-Mail Us Today

Office Hours:
M-W-F 9Am to 6Pm
T & Th 9Am to 5Pm
Sat 10Am to 2Pm

Get a Free Quote
Policy Services


First Choice Insurance Testimonials

Our Customers say it best…

“I couldn’t believe it when you told me you could save me $478 a year on my auto insurance but you did.  I went from $1460 a year to $982.  Thanks for everything” PhilB

I’ve been a customer of your office for over 10 years and your staff treats me like family.  No voice recording or 800 number pressing buttons for 15 minutes to speak with someone. A friendly voice always answers the phone.  And your rates are great too, Thanks for everything! JennaS

Ask for our quick “10 Company Quote”

  • Auto Insurance for every driver, age & vehicle
  • Tickets, Accidents, Permits, Suspended Licenses OK
  • Buy a policy by phone, fax, e-mail, mail & in person too
  • Low rates, Low or NO deposit, E-Z payments,  Instant coverage

Over 70% of our business is referrals..we must be doing something right!

For fast service and general questions e-mail us at  [email protected] or call 631-422-6650 today!

Insure all your stuff with First Choice…we care about your stuff and more importantly…WE CARE ABOUT YOU.

Established in 1987, First Choice Insurance has grown to one of the premier insurance agencies in New York State. If you live in New York State, we can help you with all your insurance needs.  We can save you money. CALL TODAY!

First Choice Insurance Auto Insurance

Even if your driving record is not picture perfect we have companies that understand that just because you have tickets or accidents it does not mean you are a bad driver.  Why pay high assigned risk rates when thousands of our policy holders don’t. What have you got to lose? Give us 10 minutes to show you what we can do for you!

See our products page for info on ALL the types of insurance we offer.  See our companies page for all the companies that we represent.  See our links page for helpful tools.  See our FAQ page for FAQ’s.

Call today for a no obligation quote  631-422-6650 or use our quote links for fast easy quoting.
You can also E-Mail us at [email protected]

progressive logo mercury logo Travelers insurance logo FEMA logo
auto one insurance logo 21st century logo GMAC logo Interboro insurance logo
Foremost Insurance group logo Countrywide Insurance logo Statewide Insurance Company logo  DEFENSIVE DRIVING ONLINE

Only $34.95 CLICK HERE